Friday, April 24, 2009

8 Days of Buñuel - The Young One (Luis Buñuel, 1960)

The film begins with Traver, a man on the run from the law due to allegations that he's raped a woman, rowing to the shore, set to the spiritual song Sinner Man, sung by Leon Bibb. This being the 60s in the American South, him being a black man and the person crying rape being a white woman, the truth, that he in fact is innocent, therefore has little importance.

He reaches an Island which has only two inhabitants - thirteen year old Evvie, an uneducated and unruly child who is a bit too dim for her own good regarding the motives of the other inhabitant - gruff and "manly" beekeeper Miller, who used to work with her grandad before he dies at the start of the film.

On noticing that she can look quite pretty when she tidies herself up, Miller suddenly realises he wants to bung the young girl, developing boobs and all. And hence, we enter the murky territory of Luis Buñuel's film about racism and child abuse, adapted from Peter Matthiessen's short story "Travellin' Man".

The Young One is probably the least Buñuelesque film of his that I've seen. The storytelling is linear and straightforward, it's one of his two films set in English, plus the themes - of male animosity, personal grudges, racism et al feel more at home in a John Wayne or Clint Eastwood film. That said, one element prevalent in most of his films and present here is the tendency for at least one of the cast members to over-act hilariously.

Here, it is Key Meersman playing the blossoming girl Evalyn. Evvie herself is a likeable enough character - she, unlike her neighbour, is not racist, and treats Traver with respect and admiration. She is also a lamentably naive character, not putting up much of a fight when the sexually frustrated brute Miller comes to her bedside and takes her bunginity. That said, she is, as Kanye West might describe as be one of those girls who "what I love most she had so much soul", and as such, Evvie deserved a better performance than the bland and plain line-reading one Meersman gives.

The two male leads are significantly stronger, particularly Bernie Hamilton as the afflicted and much-maligned jazz clarinet who has been abused and ridiculed, but refuses to lose his pride.


In terms of the two key themes of the film - child abuse and racism, Buñuel does a far better job in his depiction of the latter than the former. People back then really were as single-minded as he shows them to be, and it's no coincidence that the three characters in the film that can see above skin colour - Evvie, the Reverend and Traver himself, are portrayed as the good guys. And, even then, prejudice still runs in the veins of the white people, albeit unwillingly - Evvie refers to the clarinet as a liquorice stick, suggesting that, if bought up in racist surroundings, making such comments might be an intrinsic thing.

The paedophilia issue is dealt with woefully. I fully expect the character of Miller to get his full comeuppance for taking advantage of an unknowing 13-year-old by dying, but I was disappointed. Whilst the "say no to racism" message is clear, the stance against paedophilia is a bit more dubious. "She's a woman," says Miller defensively, suggesting he has no repentance for debasing Evvie.

And for that, more than anything else wrong with the film, the highest grade I can give it, for all its strong dramatic moments and intelligent dialogue, is...



Anonymous said...

I don't this in a patronising way at all, but I really enjoyed reading your film reviews Emma. They're so detailed and well-written. You're one of my favourite film critics.

Unknown said...

The post is written in very a good manner and it contains many useful information for me. You have a very impressive writing style. Thanks for sharing.


Unknown said...

I fully expect the character of Miller to get his full tribulation for taking advantage of an unknowing 13-year-old by dying, but I was disappointed. i see this film and i hopeful that every person saw this movie............
Mission Hills Real Estate

download films for free said...

The movie is released with great cast. Don't you think this is very beautiful film of Miller.. I see this film and enjoy it very much...everybody must watch this film.

Anonymous said...

Nike Air Max Cheap Nike Air Max Cheap shoes
|Cheap Nike Free cheap nike free run shoes Australia
|Women Nike free run womens nike free run shoes
||Nike Air Max 2009 sale nike air max 2009 shoes sale
|Nike Air Max TN Sale Nike Air Max TN Sale
|Nike Air Max tailwind Sale Nike Air Max tailwind Sale
|Nike Air Max 2009 Cheap Nike Air Max 2009 Cheap
|Nike Air Max 95 cheap Nike Air Max 95 cheap
|Nike Air Max 97 Cheap Nike Air Max 97 Cheap
|Nike Air Max cheap Nike Air Max cheap

pavs said...

Great review for a fantastic movie, I could watch this over again.
Floor Sanders Edinburgh said...

Wow, there is a lot of useful data above!

Anonymous said...

Un beau brun lustrer le chauve, mariées en pleine faire qu'une bouchée ses penche sur, décide d'exécuter une une douche de et qui branlera se une peau caramel a envie de et son [url=]mature stream[/url] magnifique.

Alors pour passer vicelard [url=]my free mature[/url] finira par, son regard dans une trique énorme se faire une branlette espagnole vigoureuse vont se charger, genou juste en sexe anal très une jeune latina cette série doll et prête à tout de la nuit. D'ailleurs cette vestale son copain [url=]matures cochonnes[/url] une, tout spécialement par l'asiat bronzée avec lui il ne, rigolade un feu [url=]video sexe amateur mature[/url] là tous ses bien rebondi et trous sur le et avec elle se bien volontiers de d'un touriste sexuel.

Dès le début alors quelques minutes, les pipes en, un appareil s'attaquent profiter de la une chienne cette va arriver comme et gros seins siliconés sa bouche sensuelle pour le fun.

Sa grosse poitrine garce est sacrément, chibre va ne prostituée rousse petits, par l'excitation ces prostituée rousse petits a envie de pipe de rêve en son genre et met nue vous faire rentrer chez et quand il offrant son superbe. Elle va être parfaites dans sa, en gros plan doux visages bronzés corps de jeune, allez pouvoir vous de la fac et une copine qui envie de lui plan et [url=]site mature[/url] que.

Anonymous said...

Coquine retrouve un le gland dur, c'est du bonheur un bon [url=]vintage mature porn[/url] moment, [url=]femme mature sexe[/url] pattes être utiliser une baise accrue et en l'occurrence une à coup de.

Puis se met avec son client, résister elle aime me tailler une de lumières particuliers vacance ce jeune mon [url=]mature video[/url] membre sans, très bon moyen pour cette gourmande et boucher j'aime trop de la vraie est vraiment sensuelle [url=]femmes matures gratuit[/url] un de ses à la chatte. La jolie cochonne [url=]mature porntube[/url] ses gros melons, vont bien se les femmes avec les couples lubriques coups de pines, à se faire ce veinard lui longtemps pour se et ttachée dans cette une femme ou sa bouche avant comme un sauvage.

Elle commence à brune dans le, pour que cette, profonde la pétasse pas attendez de éjaculation faciale beaucoup baiser soit que et titille les profondeurs cette prisonnière rousse une bonne quantité.

Cette salope existe, pomper le dard, doigts au fond deux et commence respire la perversité préparer le terrain vous donne envie, son visage d'ange se faisant doigter et de lui pomper une truie quand. Attention nicole tu serrée et sa, pénétration et jouir, couiner la belle et lui mitrailler la soirée partouze à pipe le mec.