Sunday, February 26, 2006

The most heartbreaking scenes in a 2005 film

2005 was an emotive year, and many scenes have resonated in their misery. But essential to tragedy is life, and it is for that reason that I have emitted some “obvious scenes” – Peter’s funeral in Jarhead, the begging for food/money in Cinderella Man, or the “obituary” in Proof – I just didn’t connect with them. Some of the selected scenes, are admittedly, manipulative, others just spoke out to me. Read. Enjoy. Comment. Cry.

07. “I’m your father!” - Transamerica
Far better than anything Star Wars serves up, Huffman is astonishing.

06. Finding the statue of liberty - Crash
Don says a world without opening his mouth.

05. Driving away from Ennis – Brokeback Mountain
Gyllenhaal is superb in his sadness, despair, and look of utter self-loathing as he approaches the prostitute.












---- Zone where tears have been shed ---

04. Not accepting the lollypop – Kung Fu Hustle
This scene’s a bit hazy now, because it was so long ago that’d I’d seen it, but what I do remember is that our lead, brilliant in his crappy fighting, tries to hold up a mute sweet-seller. What he doesn’t realise immediately is that she captures everything he lost – his goodness, and wishing to use kung fu for the greater good. A flashback occurs where she’d been bullied into giving up her lollypop by some bullies, and he’d rescued her. She’d tried to say thank you by giving him the lollypop, but he never accepted it. She, however, kept it, and offers it to him again. And, again, remembering how na├»ve he’d been and resentful in how things have turned out, he rejects it again. Trust me, this scene is sadder, and a lot sweeter, than it sounds.

03. Cradling the shirts – Brokeback Mountain
Ennis del Mar visits then house of Jack Twist, love of his life, his raison d’etre, intending on getting his ashes. He doesn’t; instead he finds something else – two shirts. One of these belongs to Jack, one is his, and they fit together like a glove. As Ennis remembers the Jack that he loves and had lost, he cradles the shirt, the only memory he has left of him. In this scene, Ledger is astounding, changing everything, even his breathing, to display the quiet, discomforting mourning that Ennis does. It’d be less upsetting if he just bawled.


02. “I did all I could” – Capote
Truman, after getting a telegram from Perry, rushes to see him before he gets hung, and Perry greets him with an odd mixture of sadness, knowing and acceptance. Up until now, Capote has been awash with mixed feelings about whether or not he wants Perry Smith to be hung. The perfect novel, or love? Fate opts for the former, though it’s also no thanks to Capote’s intervention, a la public readings from his judgemental novel “In Cold Blood.” When he meets Perry now, it almost seems that he knows, and in essence, so does Capote. In the most subtle of subtle scenes, Hoffman casts off any shade of camp and fights back his own tears to try to explain, yet all he can say is “I did all I could.” It sounds like such a bare-faced lie, considering everything that has happened, but I believe that with such an egocentric, ambitious temperament as Capote, maybe he really did do all he could.

01. “I wish I knew how to quit you!” – Brokeback Mountain
20 years after their first encounter, the love affair still going strong. Well, until now, where Ennis has revealed that it won’t be until November that he can see Jack. Jack Twist, 20 years older but none the wiser, can’t understand why Ennis can’t make the time to see him. From the 20 years of bottled-up frustration and rage comes the iconic “I wish I knew how to quit you!” monologue, tragic yet quasi-comedic in the inane ramblings that come out. Ennis follows with his rebuttal and the two men collapse into the floor together in a frantic embrace, which resolves nothing. The fact that Jack’s flashback of much better times follows only accentuates how destructive and heartbreaking their relationship is. In another time and place things wouldn’t have turned out this way.

10 comments:

commentator said...

Undy. Hey, I liked that Cinderella Man scene. Crowe was exceptional, and the way he battled to maintain his dignity whilst begging for money has totally overshadowed, for me at least, the fact that Howard was so obviously trying to pull our emotional strings.

Needless to say, the "Cradling the shirts" scene is another favourite of mine. This sequence alone should it make it clear for everyone that Ledger was better than Jake!

But you're quite correct in naming the "I wish I knew how to quit you!" one the most heartbreaking scene of the year. That sequence alone should earn Jake the Oscar; it was probably his best moment in the entire film. And the scene is not just heartbreaking, mind you, but distinctly well directed as well. Ang Lee was able to suggest with nothing more than an elaborate, if strangely subdued, camera move (that leaves Ledger's Ennis blurred and out of focus), that the romance was about to end & that Jack was finally willing to move on. It's brilliant. And of course, weren't I busy trying to discern every single technical detail, I'd probably have been moved to the point of tears as well. Beautiful!

maria said...

good site

rhys said...

for me, the saddest scene in CRASH was when the little girl nearly got shot. that was heartbreaking.

James said...

When Reese (June) and her family scared off the drug dealer. I thought that was sad and beautiful

Anonymous said...

Looking for information and found it at this great site... »

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Anonymous said...

This is from sparknotes, you cheat presenting it as your own. At least leave like some credit to www.sparknotes.com

Emma said...

I didn't write them - someone anonymous left them in the comments. But sure, I'll delete it.

Anonymous said...

Greetings :)

What was the number one as well as the worst movie of the year 2010 in your oppinion? In my view it would have to be:

Greatest: Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part One

Worst: A Nightmare on Elm Street


Thanks ! :) <3

Anonymous said...

Nike Air Max Cheap Nike Air Max Cheap shoes
|Cheap Nike Free cheap nike free run shoes Australia
|Women Nike free run womens nike free run shoes
||Nike Air Max 2009 sale nike air max 2009 shoes sale
|Nike Air Max TN Sale Nike Air Max TN Sale
|Nike Air Max tailwind Sale Nike Air Max tailwind Sale
|Nike Air Max 2009 Cheap Nike Air Max 2009 Cheap
|Nike Air Max 95 cheap Nike Air Max 95 cheap
|Nike Air Max 97 Cheap Nike Air Max 97 Cheap
|Nike Air Max cheap Nike Air Max cheap